We Will Seek Justice For Your Injuries

Missed Nerve Injury During Thyroid Surgery led to Paralyzed Vocal Cords – Over $525,000 Recovered in Settlement

by | Nov 16, 2026 | Case Results

Thyroid surgery takes place in a crowded part of the body. Two small nerves, called the recurrent laryngeal nerves, run alongside the thyroid gland, one on each side of the neck. These nerves control the muscles that open and close the vocal cords.

The vocal cords do far more than produce speech. They open to let air into the lungs, close to protect the airway during swallowing, and work together to produce a strong cough. Surgeons who operate in this area are trained to identify and protect these nerves throughout the procedure.

Our client, an active professional in her early fifties with a full career and social life, underwent a total thyroidectomy, which removes the entire thyroid gland, along with a central lymph node dissection. During a central lymph node dissection, the surgeon also removes lymph nodes from the front of the neck near the thyroid. She had a history of multinodular thyroid disease and difficulty swallowing

Most people who schedule thyroid surgery expect to recover within a few weeks and get back to normal life. For our client, the operation ended very differently. She left with a permanent tracheostomy, a feeding tube, and a voice she can barely use. Our firm resolved her medical malpractice claim through a settlement of more than $525,000.

Her story shows how a single surgical injury, made worse by a failure to recognize it, can permanently change a person’s life.

She was never told she could lose her voice permanently

Before the operation, her surgeon told her there was a chance she could end up with “weak” or “stunned” vocal cords. He reassured her that he would use a machine to monitor her vocal cords and make sure they were not injured.

What he did not explain was that a total thyroidectomy carries a risk of permanent vocal cord paralysis. That is a devastating injury with life-altering consequences, and a patient deserves to know about it before agreeing to surgery.

Nerve monitoring should have revealed the damage during surgery

The surgeon’s operative report stated that nerve monitoring was used throughout the procedure and that both laryngeal nerves were identified, photographed, and intact. The physician responsible for the nerve monitoring described the patient’s nerve function as “uneventful and stable.” Those descriptions were wrong.

As soon as the breathing tube was removed, the medical team noted that our client had inspiratory stridor. Stridor is a harsh, high-pitched sound that happens when air struggles to pass through a narrowed airway.

The problem should not have come as a surprise. Intraoperative neuromonitoring is technology that tracks whether the nerves are still sending signals during surgery. It gives the surgical team real-time information about nerve function, so a change in the signal is a warning that deserves immediate attention. With proper monitoring, the injury should have been recognized while the operation was still underway.

Our client was treated with medication in the recovery room and then transferred to the intensive care unit. A lung specialist placed her on BiPAP (Bilevel Positive Airway Pressure), a machine that pushes pressurized air into the lungs through a mask. She could not speak, and she could not produce a cough.

A cough is one of the body’s main defenses. Without one, a person cannot clear mucus, saliva, or food particles from the airway.

An ear, nose, and throat specialist performed a nasal laryngoscopy, using a thin camera passed through the nose to view the throat, and found the cause. Our client had suffered bilateral true vocal cord paralysis, meaning both of her vocal cords had stopped moving. Her cords were not in a midline position, and her airway had become compromised.

The damage was permanent, yet she still needed two more surgeries

The doctors monitored her briefly to see whether her vocal cords would recover. The next day, a second scope showed no movement of either vocal cord, and the paralysis was obstructing her airway. That evening she underwent a second surgery to place a tracheostomy, a surgical opening in the front of the neck that lets air reach the lungs.

The paralysis also took away our client’s ability to swallow. The following day she was taken back for a third surgery. A physician performed an upper endoscopy (EGD) and placed a percutaneous endoscopic gastrostomy tube, commonly called a PEG tube. A PEG tube passes through the wall of the abdomen directly into the stomach. It allows a patient to receive nutrition without eating or drinking by mouth.

The breaches in the standard of care left our client with permanent and irreversible damage to both recurrent laryngeal nerves, which caused paralysis of both vocal cords. She now lives with a permanent tracheostomy. She can no longer speak without great strain and has become mostly non-verbal. She depends on a feeding tube for the nutrition she cannot take by mouth.

Simple tasks such as asking a question or talking with family became a struggle. A tracheostomy requires constant care and cleaning. Mealtimes, which most people enjoy with family and friends, turn into a medical routine. An injury of this kind reaches into work, relationships, and independence for the rest of a person’s life.

Know the warning signs after thyroid or neck surgery

Some hoarseness after neck surgery can be temporary. Certain symptoms, however, call for prompt medical attention and a closer look at what happened in the operating room:

  • Noisy, high-pitched breathing
  • A lost voice, or a weak and breathy voice that does not improve
  • An inability to cough with force
  • Choking or coughing while eating or drinking
  • Shortness of breath or a tight feeling in the throat

If you notice any of these symptoms, get medical care first. Then request complete copies of your medical records and keep a written timeline of your treatment and symptoms, because any review of your case will rely on that file.

Surgical errors are not always obvious, and medical records do not always tell the full story. In our client’s case, the record called the operation uneventful even though she showed signs of a serious airway problem as soon as the breathing tube came out. Uncovering the truth took a careful review of what the surgical team knew and when the team knew it.

Archives

FindLaw Network