We Will Seek Justice For Your Injuries

Mispositioned Screws led to Second Surgery and Loss of Motion in Wrist – Over $500,000 Recovered in Settlement

by | Nov 20, 2026 | Case Results

Most patients leave the operating room trusting that their surgeon will tell them if something went wrong. In this case, the x-ray taken at the patient’s first appointment after surgery showed a problem. Nobody told her. For months, she pushed through therapy and pain while misplaced hardware sat inside her wrist joint.

Our firm pursued the claim on our client’s behalf, and the case resolved in a settlement of more than $500,000. No amount of money can give back the full use of her hand. A fair recovery does, however, help an injured person face the costs of future medical care and the financial strain of being unable to keep working in a career she had built over 17 years.

A serious wrist fracture required surgery

Our client tripped over a parking lot barrier and injured her dominant wrist. Imaging confirmed a comminuted fracture of the distal radius, with fracture lines extending into the joint. A comminuted fracture means the bone has broken into several pieces rather than snapping cleanly in two. Breaks like this usually cannot heal properly on their own, because the fragments must be returned to their proper position and held there.

Four days after the fall, she underwent a procedure called an open reduction and internal fixation, often shortened to ORIF. Her surgeon secured the bone with a plate and nine screws. During an ORIF, the surgeon opens the injured area, realigns the broken pieces, and attaches metal hardware to stabilize the bone while it heals.

Precise placement matters. Each screw needs to grip the bone firmly without breaking through into the neighboring joint.

The first x-ray after surgery revealed a problem

About two weeks after the operation, at her first post-operative appointment, an x-ray was taken. The radiologist reported that the tip of one screw appeared to extend past the articular surface of the distal radius and recommended comparing that finding with the operative history. The distal radius is the end of the forearm bone closest to the hand. Its articular surface is the smooth, cartilage-covered area where the radius meets the small bones of the wrist, allowing the joint to glide. Metal poking through that surface can rub against cartilage every time the wrist moves.

The medical records do not show that the provider who saw her that day passed the finding to her surgeon. Our client was never told what the x-ray showed. Instead, she was sent to occupational therapy and given aggressive goals. Put simply, she was asked to work hard at moving a joint that had hardware intruding into it.

In therapy she reported pain, limited motion in her fingers and wrist, and swelling. She later had sharp pain along the outside of her wrist when she turned her palm upward or grasped objects. Her therapist noted concern about swelling throughout her hand.

At a follow-up appointment about eight weeks after surgery, her surgeon wrote in the chart that she was concerned there might be a screw inside the joint. Even so, no MRI or CT scan was ordered. That concern, along with the patient’s pain and stiffness, was an opportunity to investigate. Advanced imaging of this kind gives doctors a detailed, three-dimensional view of where surgical hardware sits in relation to the joint, which a standard x-ray may not fully capture.

A second opinion uncovered three screws inside the joint

After five months of therapy, she had made little progress. Neither her swelling nor her wrist motion had improved, so she sought a second opinion. The new orthopedic surgeon ordered MRI and CT scans. The MRI showed mal-positioned screws, and the CT showed three screws penetrating the articular surface of the distal radius.

She then needed another operation, about nine months after the first. Before surgery she was diagnosed with a stiff wrist, wrist pain, stiffness in three fingers, and scar tissue adhesions in the wrist and forearm. During the procedure, the surgeon confirmed three screws inside her wrist joint, removed all of the hardware, and treated the stiffness in her fingers.

The original x-ray had flagged one screw. The scans and the corrective surgery showed three.

The second surgery did not restore her wrist. She still does not have normal function of her dominant hand and arm. She continues to deal with persistent pain, swelling, and stiffness, along with permanent joint damage and limited range of motion. She had worked for the same employer for 17 years. When her contract ended, her pain and physical limitations kept her from applying for another available position there. For someone who relies on her dominant hand, these losses reach into nearly every part of daily life.

Why these facts support a medical malpractice claim

Medical malpractice occurs when a health care provider fails to meet the accepted standard of care and that failure causes harm. Not every bad outcome qualifies. Surgery carries real risks, and complications can happen even when a doctor does everything right.

What set this case apart was how the complication was handled once it appeared. Three concerns stood out.

The warning sign was documented but not acted on. The x-ray at the first post-operative visit already showed a screw tip beyond the joint surface. Later, the surgeon wrote down her own concern about a screw in the joint but ordered no further imaging.

The patient was kept in the dark. Without knowing about the finding, she could not ask questions, seek another opinion sooner, or make informed choices about her own care.

Her symptoms did not lead to further testing. Ongoing reports of pain, swelling, and stiffness were met with more therapy rather than the imaging that eventually revealed the problem.

Each of these failures added to the delay. A hardware problem that could have been addressed early instead stayed in place until a different doctor went looking for it.

Archives

FindLaw Network